Histopathology of Lung
Disease in the Connective
Tissue Diseases
Marina Vivero, MD, Robert F. Padera, MD, PhD*
INTRODUCTION
The pathologic correlates of interstitial lung disease (ILD) secondary to connective
tissue disease (CTD) comprise a diverse group of histologic patterns that can vary
greatly within a given CTD and may in fact display significant overlap between distinct
CTDs.1 Lung biopsies in patients with CTD-associated ILD tend to demonstrate simultaneous involvement of multiple anatomic compartments of the lung, including the
airways, alveolar septa, alveolar spaces, pleura, and vasculature, and often demonstrate acute, subacute, and chronic lesions within the same specimen, indicating an
ongoing pathophysiologic process.1,2 All CTDs can result in nonspecific histologic
The authors have no disclosures to make.
Department of Pathology, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, 75 Francis Street, Boston, MA
02115, USA
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: rpadera@partners.org
KEYWORDS
Pathology Histopathology Interstitial lung disease Connective tissue disease
Rheumatoid arthritis Scleroderma Myositis
KEY POINTS
Although there is substantial histologic overlap among the pulmonary manifestations of
different connective tissue diseases (CTDs), certain patterns may favor 1 CTD over
another; occasionally, distinctive histologic clues may be present.
CTDs may present with acute, subacute, and/or chronic pleuropulmonary manifestations,
often mixed within the same biopsy, representing ongoing disease.
Patients with CTD may be taking immunosuppressive medications and are vulnerable to
certain infections; both of these can result in histologic changes that are similar to direct
pulmonary manifestations of the underlying CTD and can represent diagnostic dilemmas
for the pathologist.
A multidisciplinary approach involving the pathologist, rheumatologist, pulmonologist,
and radiologist allows for correlation of the clinical, radiologic, and pathologic findings
to arrive at the proper diagnosis.
Rheum Dis Clin N Am - (2015) -–-
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rdc.2014.12.002 rheumatic.theclinics.com
0889-857X/15/$ – see front matter 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
patterns that are essentially indistinguishable from the idiopathic interstitial pneumonias; however, in the setting of known CTD, the probability that the lung findings are
caused by the patient’s underlying systemic disease must be considered.3,4 Certain
histologic patterns do tend to predominate in each defined CTD, and it is possible
in many cases to confirm connective tissue-associated lung disease and guide patient
management using surgical lung biopsy.
Some pulmonary pathologies seen in patients with CTD may not be a direct manifestation of the effect of CTD on the lung, but may be related to therapy or to other systemic complications of the patient’s CTD. These conditions can result in significant
histologic changes that can make it difficult to determine which findings can be truly
be ascribed to involvement by the patient’s CTD.5–7 For example, a patient with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) treated with methotrexate may develop a cellular nonspecific interstitial pneumonitis (NSIP) secondary to drug toxicity; this may mimic cellular NSIP that
could represent the bona fide onset of RA-associated ILD, or it could mimic the histologic pattern of a viral pneumonia to which the patient would be predisposed secondary to immunosuppression. The recognition and contextualization of these processes
are best accomplished via review by a multidisciplinary team, including pathologists
with specialized training in thoracic pathology or significant experience reading nonneoplastic surgical lung biopsies, rheumatologists, pulmonologists, and radiologists.
This article will cover the pulmonary pathologies seen in RA, systemic sclerosis,
myositis, systemic lupus erythematosus, Sjo ¨ gren syndrome, and mixed CTD.
HISTOLOGY OF LUNG DISEASE IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
Perhaps more so than any of the other CTDs, lung disease in patients with RA exhibits
a wide variety of histopathologic patterns that can affect all of the major compartments
of the lung. Pleural effusion and pleuritis are common initial pleuropulmonary manifestations of RA and may be appreciated grossly and microscopically as acute fibrinous
pleuritis, fibrous pleural thickening, and/or pleural adhesions.8–10 Cytologic preparations of pleural fluid may have characteristic aggregates of amorphous debris and
degenerated neutrophils.11 Single or multiple rheumatoid nodules (Fig. 1) may be
Fig. 1. Rheumatoid nodule in a patient with RA. Rheumatoid nodules possess a central area
of amorphous, eosinophilic necrobiosis surrounded by a rim of epithelioid histiocytes and
occasional giant cells. A mixed inflammatory infiltrate including occasional neutrophils
may line the inner perimeter of the histiocyte rim, and there may be finely granular basophilic material within areas of necrobiosis, imparting a dirty appearance at low power.
100 original magnification.
2 Vivero & Padera
found in the pleura, interlobular septa, or alveolar interstitium; although not the most
common manifestation, they are considered the most specific finding of RA-ILD.
These nodules, which can measure up to 2 to 3 cm, are identical to those seen in
the subcutaneous tissues, consisting of sterile central necrobiosis surrounded by
epithelioid histiocytes.5,8,9
The most frequent histologic patterns of ILD among RA patients are NSIP (Fig. 2), followed closely by usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) (Figs. 3 and 4), accounting for 30%
to 67% and 13% to 57% of RA-associated ILD, respectively.2,3,12–17 Some studies have
noted an equal or greater incidence of UIP histology in RA-ILD, although smaller sample
sizes and the high frequency of both ILD patterns among this patient population may
account for the discrepancy.14,18 The histologic appearance of RA-associated NSIP
(RA-NSIP) or UIP (RA-UIP) is identical to that seen in idiopathic NSIP and UIP, although
the occurrence of more prominent interstitial lymphoid aggregates, either within alveolar septal walls or associated with small airways, has been noted in several studies.5,9
Indeed, the presence of lymphoid aggregates, and specifically germinal centers, has
been reported to be significantly greater in RA-UIP than in UIP, and has been suggested
to be a distinguishing feature of RA-ILD.12,15,16,19 Similarly, the frequency of fibroblast
foci has been reported to be lesser in RA-UIP than in idiopathic UIP.3,16
Various types of inflammatory airway disease including bronchiectasis, chronic
bronchitis, and follicular bronchiolitis are often seen as a secondary finding in a background of NSIP or UIP.17,20,21 Acute and subacute processes such as diffuse alveolar
damage (DAD) and organizing pneumonia (OP) can be seen in patients with established RA-ILD, often in the clinical setting of an acute exacerbation, but they can occasionally represent the initial pulmonary manifestation of RA.5,14,18,22 Vasculitis,
capillaritis, and pulmonary hemorrhage are rare acute manifestations of RA-ILD;
chronic vascular manifestations, when present, are usually a result of underlying
fibrotic lung disease.23
HISTOLOGY OF LUNG DISEASE IN SYSTEMIC SCLEROSIS (SCLERODERMA)
ILD occurs in up to 80% of patients with systemic sclerosis (SSc), making ILD more
prevalent in SSc than in any other CTD. The most characteristic histologic features
Fig. 2. Cellular NSIP in a patient with RA. Cellular NSIP is characterized by uniform expansion of the alveolar septal interstitium by a chronic inflammatory infiltrate composed primarily of small lymphocytes intermixed with occasional plasma cells and histiocytes.
Prominent lymphoid aggregates and germinal centers are characteristic of RA. 20 original
magnification.
Histopathology of Lung Disease 3
of ILD in SSc are dense interstitial fibrosis and pulmonary hypertensive vascular
changes.24,25 The most common pattern of interstitial fibrosis in SSc is fibrotic NSIP
(Fig. 5), manifesting as dense, paucicellular interstitial fibrosis that maintains the underlying lung architecture and often spares the immediate subpleural area.26–28 As
the lung disease progresses, the areas of fibrosis may become confluent and appear
as honeycomb or end-stage lung. Patients with SSc may also manifest their ILD as a
typical UIP pattern with temporal and spatial heterogeneity, in contrast to the diffusely
uniform fibrosis of NSIP. The pulmonary hypertensive vascular changes (Fig. 6) are
manifested as concentric intimal thickening by fibromyxoid tissue and mild medial hypertrophy leading to thickened and stenotic pulmonary arterioles. The degree of pulmonary hypertensive changes is often more severe and out of proportion to the degree
of interstitial fibrosis.29 Although true vasculitis and pulmonary hemorrhage can occasionally be seen, it is a fairly uncommon feature in this disease.30 Patients with SSc
often have esophageal dysmotility with associated gastrointestinal reflux; this can
Fig. 3. UIP in a patient with RA. The UIP pattern is characterized by patchy, predominantly
subpleural interstitial fibrosis. Interstitial fibrosis in UIP, unlike NSIP, appears temporally
heterogenous, with some areas of dense eosinophilic or elastotic mature interstitial
collagen and other areas of looser, immature myxoid collagenous matrix with discrete,
lens-shaped nodes of fibroblastic proliferation (fibroblast foci). These areas of involvement
often demonstrate a characteristic, sharply demarcated interface with completely uninvolved lung parenchyma. As in RA-NSIP, an increased number of lymphoid aggregates
and germinal centers are present in RA-UIP. 1 original magnification.
Fig. 4. UIP in a patient with RA. A fibroblastic focus is seen at the interface between dense
fibrosis and normal lung. 100 original magnification.
4 Vivero & Padera
lead to superimposed aspiration pneumonia that may or may not be clinically apparent
but can complicate the interpretation of the surgical lung biopsy.
HISTOLOGY OF LUNG DISEASE IN MYOSITIS
Chronic pulmonary disease in polymyositis and dermatomyositis (PM-DM) consists of
varying degrees of cellular interstitial pneumonitis that are best characterized as NSIP
(Fig. 7).2,6,22,31–35 Most case series have described varying degrees of fibrosis accompanying the cellular interstitial infiltrates of PM-DM, including 1 study indicating
approximately a 40% prevalence of cellular NSIP and 53% prevalence of mixed
cellular and fibrotic NSIP in myositis patients, with only rare cases of pure fibrotic
NSIP.33 The OP pattern (Fig. 8) can be seen in PM-DM patients, either as an isolated
manifestation or superimposed on a background of NSIP, and it has been histologically confirmed to resolve with steroid treatment.32,34,36 UIP pattern histology has been
Fig. 5. Fibrotic NSIP in a patient with SSc. Fibrotic NSIP is characterized by dense, paucicellular interstitial fibrosis that largely maintains the underlying lung architecture and is
spatially and temporally homogeneous. 40 original magnification.
Fig. 6. Pulmonary hypertensive vascular disease in a patient with SSc. The arteriolar wall is
thickened and the lumen narrowed by a fibrointimal proliferation with no significant
inflammation. 200 original magnification.
Histopathology of Lung Disease 5
described in PM-DM and, similar to RA-UIP, it often contains at least moderately
cellular areas consisting of lymphoplasmacytic or mononuclear infiltrates.2,16,31,34,36
The UIP pattern may arise more frequently in patients with the antisynthetase antibody